The journey to comprehend the intricate fabric of existence often leads us through the winding paths of philosophical and religious inquiry, challenging us to transcend the familiar terrain of duality. At the heart of this exploration lies the quest to reconcile the apparent contradictions within and around us, seeking a vantage point from which the interconnected essence of all things becomes discernible. This quest, though diverse in its expressions across cultures and epochs, shares a common thread—the pursuit of a deeper, unified understanding of reality that transcends the binary oppositions of conventional thought.
My foray into this realm was catalyzed by early encounters with the profound works of Kitaro Nishida, particularly “An Inquiry into the Good,” Daisetz Suzuki’s insightful explorations in “Essays in Zen Buddhism,” and the mystical depth of Meister Eckhart’s sermons and writings. These seminal readings, undertaken in the fervor of youth, were not merely intellectual endeavors; they were transformative experiences that indelibly shaped my approach to understanding the world.
Alongside these were the contemplative insights of Thomas Merton, whose writings bridged the mystic depths of Christianity with the profound simplicity of Eastern wisdom, and the timeless teachings of the Heart Sutra and the Bible, each echoing the profound theme of unity amidst the manifold. The Heart Sutra’s assertion that “Form is emptiness, emptiness is form” and the Biblical invitation to “Be still, and know that I am God” (Psalm 46:10), paired with Eckhart’s radical notion that true knowledge of God transcends all human understanding, serve as poignant reminders of the journey beyond duality.
This piece endeavors to weave together the insights gleaned from these luminaries and sacred texts, tracing the intricate patterns they reveal in the fabric of existence. It is an exploration of how diverse traditions converge on the theme of transcending duality, each offering unique perspectives yet collectively pointing toward a transcendent understanding of reality.
The Concept of Non-Duality
At the core of many philosophical and spiritual traditions lies the concept of non-duality, an understanding that challenges the pervasive notion of separation between self and other, subject and object, the divine and the mundane. Non-duality suggests that these apparent dichotomies are not inherently distinct but are manifestations of a singular, interconnected reality.
Kitaro Nishida, in his seminal work “An Inquiry into the Good,” delves into the depths of this concept through the lens of ‘pure experience.’ He posits that at the most fundamental level of consciousness, there is no division between the experiencing subject and the experienced object; there is simply experience itself, undivided and indivisible. This state of pure experience serves as the foundation upon which all distinctions and dualities are subsequently constructed, revealing that at the heart of existence lies a unity that precedes all differentiation.
Nishida’s exploration of non-duality extends further into the notion of ‘the self-identity of absolute contradictories,’ a principle that posits the coexistence and mutual identity of seemingly opposing elements within the absolute. This idea, radical in its assertion, suggests that true reality encompasses and transcends all dualities, embodying a unity that is both immanent and transcendent.
The resonance of non-duality is not confined to the philosophical realm but finds expression in the spiritual teachings of the Heart Sutra, a foundational text in Mahayana Buddhism. The sutra’s profound declaration that “Form is emptiness, emptiness is form” encapsulates the essence of non-duality, inviting practitioners to perceive the inherent emptiness of all phenomena, thereby transcending the conventional distinctions that bind the mind.
This concept of non-duality, though articulated in various ways across different traditions, offers a transformative perspective on existence. It invites us into a deeper engagement with reality, one that recognizes the fundamental unity underlying the diversity of forms, and in doing so, challenges us to transcend the limitations of dualistic thinking.
Zen Buddhism and the Heart Sutra
Zen Buddhism, with its profound emphasis on direct experience and the transcendence of conceptual thought, offers a compelling exploration of non-duality that resonates deeply with the teachings of the Heart Sutra. This connection is exemplified in the work of Daisetz Suzuki, whose “Essays in Zen Buddhism” delve into the essence of Zen practice and its philosophical underpinnings, highlighting the sutra’s pivotal role in Zen thought.
The Heart Sutra, revered in Zen and Mahayana Buddhism, succinctly captures the essence of Buddhist wisdom through its enigmatic proclamation: “Form is emptiness, emptiness is form.” This statement is not a negation of reality but an invitation to perceive the interconnectedness and inherent emptiness of all phenomena, which, paradoxically, is full of potentiality. In Zen, this understanding is not reached through intellectual analysis but through meditation, intuition, and the direct experience of suchness (tathata).
Suzuki’s interpretations of Zen Buddhism emphasize the liberation from dualistic thinking that the Heart Sutra advocates. He elucidates how Zen practice, with its koans and meditative disciplines, aims to shatter the conventional constructs of the mind, leading practitioners to a direct encounter with the ultimate reality, beyond words and concepts. This approach aligns with the Heart Sutra’s teaching, guiding one to see beyond the illusory separations and to realize the non-dual nature of existence.
The influence of the Heart Sutra in Zen and its embodiment in Suzuki’s work illuminate a path toward understanding the profound unity underlying the multiplicity of forms. This perspective not only enriches the philosophical discourse on non-duality but also offers practical insights into living with awareness and compassion, recognizing the interconnected fabric of all life.
Interfaith Dialogue and Mysticism
The dialogue between Zen Buddhism and Christian mysticism, particularly through the interactions between Daisetz Suzuki and Thomas Merton, represents a fertile ground for exploring non-duality across spiritual traditions. This interfaith exchange highlights the universal quest for a deeper understanding of the divine and the nature of existence, transcending the boundaries of individual religions.
Suzuki’s profound understanding of Zen Buddhism and his efforts to articulate its essence to a Western audience found a receptive interlocutor in Thomas Merton, a Trappist monk whose own spiritual writings delve deeply into the mystical heart of Christianity. Merton’s fascination with Zen, and Eastern spirituality more broadly, was fueled by his recognition of the common ground shared with the mystical traditions within his own faith, particularly the emphasis on experiential knowledge of the divine and the transcendence of dualistic thinking.
This interfaith dialogue is enriched by the contemplation of key Biblical teachings that resonate with non-dualistic thought. For instance, the Christian notion of “dying to oneself” (Galatians 2:20) echoes the Zen call to let go of the ego and the illusion of separation, fostering a direct encounter with the divine presence that pervades all things. This mystical union, where the individual self is transcended in favor of a profound unity with God, mirrors the non-dual realization sought in Zen practice.
Merton’s writings, such as “New Seeds of Contemplation,” explore these themes, advocating for a contemplative life that seeks not merely the knowledge about God but a transformative experience of God. This approach, deeply aligned with Suzuki’s exposition of Zen, underscores the potential for interfaith dialogue to illuminate the shared human longing for connection with the transcendent, beyond the confines of conceptual frameworks and religious dogma.
The fruitful exchange between Suzuki and Merton, and the broader conversation between Zen Buddhism and Christian mysticism, serve as a testament to the universal nature of the mystical pursuit. It reveals that at the core of various religious traditions lies a common thread of seeking unity with the ultimate reality, a journey that transcends the superficial differences and celebrates the underlying unity of all existence.
Contemplative Christianity and Thomas Merton
Thomas Merton, a figure synonymous with contemplative Christianity, brought to the forefront the rich tradition of Christian mysticism with its profound insights into non-duality and the unity of all existence. Merton’s spiritual journey and extensive writings offer a bridge between the contemplative practices of the East and the mystical heritage of the West, illuminating the shared pursuit of a direct encounter with the divine that transcends conceptual boundaries.
In works like “New Seeds of Contemplation,” Merton articulates a vision of contemplation that goes beyond mere reflection or meditation on divine truths. He describes it as a total immersion in the presence of God, where the boundaries between the self and the divine dissolve, revealing a deep, underlying unity. This mystical experience, akin to the non-dual realization in Eastern traditions, underscores the essence of contemplative Christianity—the direct, intimate experience of God’s presence that defies dualistic categorization.
Merton’s engagement with the Heart Sutra and his dialogue with figures like Daisetz Suzuki further enriched his understanding of non-duality. He saw in the Heart Sutra’s teachings on emptiness a reflection of the mystical path within Christianity, where the relinquishment of the ego and the abandonment of all conceptual frameworks lead to a direct encounter with the divine reality. Merton’s interpretation of Biblical passages, such as “Be still, and know that I am God” (Psalm 46:10), echoes this sentiment, emphasizing the importance of silence, stillness, and the cessation of the ego’s activity as pathways to experiencing God’s presence.
Through his writings and interfaith dialogues, Merton demonstrated that the contemplative core of Christianity shares profound similarities with the non-dualistic approaches of Eastern spirituality. He highlighted the universal human longing for a transcendent experience of unity with the divine, a longing that transcends religious labels and doctrinal differences.
Merton’s legacy in bridging Eastern and Western spiritual traditions lies not only in his intellectual contributions but also in his lived example of a contemplative life. His journey underscores the potential of contemplative practice to lead individuals to a transformative realization of non-duality, where the distinctions between self and other, human and divine, are transcended in favor of a direct, unmediated encounter with the ultimate reality.
Comparative Perspectives Across Traditions
The exploration of non-duality and the quest for a deeper understanding of existence transcend cultural and religious boundaries, unveiling a shared human endeavor to comprehend the interconnectedness of all life. This pursuit is vividly illustrated in the teachings of Zen Buddhism, Christian mysticism, and the philosophical inquiries of figures like Kitaro Nishida, each presenting a unique yet converging perspective on the themes of unity and transcendence.
The Heart Sutra’s profound declaration, “Form is emptiness, emptiness is form,” finds a resonant echo in the Christian mystical tradition, particularly in the teachings of Meister Eckhart. Eckhart, known for his contemplative insights, taught that in the act of “letting go” or “detachment” (Abgeschiedenheit), the individual will is surrendered to the Divine Will. He posited that when one ceases to will independently, God begins to will through the individual, a state of union where the self is no longer distinct from the divine. This mystical surrender is akin to the non-dual realization in Zen, where the dissolution of ego and conceptual frameworks leads to direct experience of the ultimate reality.
Eckhart’s assertion that “The knower and the known are one. God and I, we are one in knowledge” parallels the Zen admonition to “kill the Buddha if you meet him on the road.” This striking Zen metaphor emphasizes the necessity of transcending even the most revered religious symbols and teachings to experience enlightenment directly. Similarly, Eckhart’s idea that truly knowing God means transcending conventional notions of God reflects a profound non-duality, where the ultimate encounter with the divine transcends all forms and concepts.
Furthermore, Eckhart’s teachings on the Godhead, where God is beyond all names, forms, and activities, mirror the Zen focus on experiencing reality as it is, unmediated by the mind’s constructs. The Zen practice of zazen (sitting meditation) and the Christian practice of contemplative prayer both aim at this realization, guiding practitioners to a state of being where dualistic distinctions dissolve, and a direct, unmediated awareness of the divine presence is attained.
The philosophical journey of Kitaro Nishida, exploring “pure experience” and the “self-identity of absolute contradictories,” complements these spiritual insights. Nishida’s work, bridging Eastern and Western thought, offers a conceptual framework that resonates with the non-dualistic essence found in the teachings of Eckhart and the Zen tradition.
The interfaith dialogue between Daisetz Suzuki and Thomas Merton, highlighting the common ground between Zen Buddhism and Christian mysticism, further underscores the universality of the mystical quest. Their exchange reveals that the aspiration to transcend dualistic thinking and directly encounter the ultimate reality is a universal human longing, expressed through diverse traditions, each offering a unique pathway to understanding the profound interconnectedness of all things.
Phenomenological Connections
The exploration of non-duality and the quest for direct, unmediated experience find intriguing parallels in the Western philosophical tradition of phenomenology. Phenomenology, initiated by Edmund Husserl and further developed by thinkers like Martin Heidegger and Maurice Merleau-Ponty, emphasizes the study of phenomena as they appear in conscious experience, seeking to uncover the structures of consciousness without presuppositions.
This phenomenological approach resonates with the non-dualistic perspectives of Zen Buddhism, Christian mysticism, and Nishida’s philosophy, particularly in its commitment to bracketing out (epoché) the taken-for-granted distinctions between subject and object, observer and observed. By focusing on the lived experience and the “things themselves,” phenomenology aligns with the Eastern and mystical Christian emphasis on encountering reality directly, beyond the constructs of conceptual thought.
The phenomenological concept of “intentionality,” the idea that consciousness is always consciousness of something, echoes the non-dualistic understanding that the perceiver and the perceived are not separate but are part of a continuous field of experience. This notion parallels Nishida’s idea of “pure experience,” where the distinction between subject and object dissolves in the immediacy of experience.
Furthermore, Heidegger’s exploration of “Being” (Dasein) and the notion of “Being-in-the-world” highlight the inseparability of the individual from the broader context of existence, a concept that mirrors the non-dualistic insight that the self is not an isolated entity but is intimately connected with the whole of reality. This perspective is akin to the Zen understanding of “interbeing,” where all phenomena are interconnected and interdependent.
The dialogue between phenomenology and Eastern thought, as well as the mystical insights of figures like Thomas Merton and Meister Eckhart, opens up fertile ground for a deeper understanding of non-duality. It underscores the potential of phenomenological methods to enrich the exploration of spiritual and philosophical traditions, offering a bridge between the analytic scrutiny of consciousness and the experiential wisdom of non-dualistic practices.
By drawing on phenomenological insights, we can deepen our appreciation of the universal human endeavor to transcend the limitations of dualistic thinking and to embrace a more integrated, holistic view of reality. This endeavor, shared across diverse cultural and philosophical landscapes, highlights the profound interconnectedness of all forms of inquiry into the nature of existence.
Personal Reflections
Reflecting on the rich tapestry of philosophical and spiritual insights that have shaped my understanding of non-duality, I am struck by the profound impact of early encounters with the works of Kitaro Nishida, Daisetz Suzuki, Thomas Merton, and the mystical teachings of Meister Eckhart, alongside the timeless teachings of the Heart Sutra and the Bible. These diverse sources, each resonant with the theme of transcending dualities, have not only informed my intellectual pursuits but have deeply influenced my personal worldview and spiritual practice.
Nishida’s exploration of “pure experience” and the “self-identity of absolute contradictories” challenged me to reconsider the nature of reality and the interconnectedness of all things. Suzuki’s interpretations of Zen Buddhism, emphasizing direct experience and the dissolution of conceptual boundaries, offered a pathway to understanding the essence of mindfulness and presence. Merton’s contemplative writings, bridging the mystic depths of Christianity with the simplicity of Eastern wisdom, provided a model for integrating spiritual practice into daily life, while Meister Eckhart’s insights into the soul’s union with God, where one ceases to will so that God may will, revealed the depth of non-dualistic mysticism within the Christian tradition.
The Heart Sutra’s declaration that “Form is emptiness, emptiness is form” and the Biblical exhortation to “Be still, and know that I am God” (Psalm 46:10), along with Eckhart’s teachings on the Godhead and the transcendence of knowing God beyond concepts, serve as continual reminders of the importance of looking beyond surface appearances to the underlying unity of existence. These teachings have encouraged me to embrace stillness and silence, recognizing them as gateways to a deeper awareness of the divine presence that permeates all things.
My engagement with these diverse traditions has underscored the value of interfaith dialogue and cross-cultural exploration in enriching one’s spiritual journey. It has revealed that the quest for a non-dual understanding of reality is not confined to any single tradition but is a universal aspiration, manifesting in myriad forms across the human experience.
As I reflect on this journey, I am reminded of the transformative power of reading, contemplation, and open-hearted engagement with the world’s wisdom traditions. These experiences have not only expanded my intellectual horizons but have also nurtured a sense of interconnectedness and compassion that guides my interactions with others and with the world around me.
Pure Experience Unveiled
In traversing the landscapes of philosophy and spirituality, the journey through the realms of non-duality reveals a profound unity underlying the rich diversity of human thought and experience. The explorations of Kitaro Nishida, Daisetz Suzuki, Thomas Merton, and Meister Eckhart, alongside the ancient wisdom of the Heart Sutra and the Bible, weave a multifaceted tapestry that speaks to a universal human aspiration: to transcend the confines of dualistic thinking and to glimpse the interconnected essence of all existence.
This journey, marked by moments of profound insight and transformative realization, challenges us to look beyond the surface distinctions that fragment our world, urging us to embrace a deeper vision of unity that honors the interconnectedness of life. It is a path that invites us to dissolve the boundaries that separate self from other, humanity from the divine, inviting us into a direct encounter with the ultimate reality that is both the ground and the mystery of our being.
As we reflect on the insights gleaned from diverse traditions, we find that the quest for non-duality is not merely an intellectual exercise but a lived experience that shapes our understanding of the world and our place within it. It is an invitation to embody the wisdom of interconnectedness, to live with compassion and mindfulness, recognizing the sacred thread that binds us to each other and to the cosmos.
In the end, the exploration of non-duality offers not only a philosophical or spiritual insight but a vision of hope—a reminder that beneath the apparent chaos and division of our world lies a deeper order and harmony. By engaging with this vision, we are called to act with greater awareness and responsibility, contributing to the healing and wholeness of our world.
As we continue on this journey, let us carry with us the humility and openness to learn from the wisdom of all traditions, embracing the beauty of diversity while seeking the unity that underlies the manifold expressions of life. In doing so, we honor the legacy of those who have walked this path before us and light a beacon for those who will follow, weaving together a future that reflects the profound interconnectedness at the heart of all existence.
Tom’s Blog 